For travelers seeking a rich historical immersion with a touch of melancholic beauty and a more intimate urban scale, Edinburgh is the superior choice. However, if your heart beats for relentless energy, unparalleled diversity, and an almost overwhelming array of world-class attractions, New York City is the undisputed champion.
New York City, USA comes out ahead more often in this comparison. Check live prices before you book, especially if your dates are flexible.
Choosing between the historic charm of Edinburgh, Scotland, and the vibrant energy of New York City, USA, is a delightful dilemma for any traveler. Edinburgh offers a journey back in time, with its medieval Old Town, imposing castle, and cobblestone streets whispering tales of centuries past. It's a city that encourages slow exploration, where hidden closes and panoramic views from Arthur's Seat are rewards for the curious.
In contrast, New York City is a pulsating metropolis, a global hub of culture, commerce, and endless entertainment. From iconic skyscrapers and world-class museums to diverse culinary scenes and Broadway shows, the Big Apple promises an experience that is both exhilarating and expansive. While Edinburgh invites you to wander, New York City beckons you to dive headfirst into its dynamic rhythm.
| Month | Edinburgh, Scotland High | Edinburgh, Scotland Rain | New York City, USA High | New York City, USA Rain |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan | 43°F | 70mm | 37°F | 75mm |
| Feb | 45°F | 50mm | 41°F | 65mm |
| Mar | 48°F | 55mm | 50°F | 90mm |
| Apr | 52°F | 45mm | 61°F | 95mm |
| May | 57°F | 50mm | 70°F | 90mm |
| Jun | 63°F | 60mm | 79°F | 85mm |
| Jul | 66°F | 65mm | 84°F | 80mm |
| Aug | 64°F | 70mm | 82°F | 75mm |
| Sep | 61°F | 60mm | 75°F | 70mm |
| Oct | 54°F | 75mm | 64°F | 85mm |
| Nov | 48°F | 70mm | 54°F | 90mm |
| Dec | 45°F | 75mm | 43°F | 80mm |
For Edinburgh, aim for late spring (May-June) or early autumn (September) for pleasant temperatures and fewer crowds. New York City shines in late spring (April-June) and early autumn (September-October) when the weather is ideal for exploring without the extreme heat of summer or the chill of winter.
Browse Lonely Planet, Fodor's, Rick Steves, and more on Amazon — packed with maps, itineraries, and local tips.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
We'll send you the best destinations to visit each month — right timing, less crowds.