For travelers seeking dramatic natural landscapes, unique geological wonders, and diverse activities from stargazing to volcano viewing, the Big Island, Hawaii, USA, is the standout choice. If your priority is classic Caribbean beach relaxation, vibrant snorkeling, and a more compact island experience with easy accessibility, St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands, is your perfect match.
Big Island, Hawaii comes out ahead more often in this comparison. Check live prices before you book, especially if your dates are flexible.
Choosing between the vast, diverse landscapes of the Big Island, Hawaii, USA, and the sun-drenched, vibrant shores of St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands, offers two distinct tropical paradise experiences. The Big Island captivates with its dramatic volcanic terrain, from active lava flows to snow-capped peaks, presenting a unique blend of natural wonders and cultural richness. In contrast, St. Thomas enchants with its postcard-perfect beaches, turquoise waters teeming with marine life, and a lively Caribbean atmosphere that beckons relaxation and adventure.
Both destinations promise unforgettable tropical getaways, but they cater to different desires. If you seek awe-inspiring geological formations, unparalleled stargazing, and a sense of raw, untamed beauty, the Big Island calls. Conversely, if your dream vacation involves pristine white-sand beaches, vibrant coral reefs perfect for snorkeling, and a taste of Caribbean charm with readily accessible amenities, St. Thomas might be your ideal choice.
| Month | Big Island, Hawaii High | Big Island, Hawaii Rain | St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands High | St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands Rain |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan | 75°F | 108mm | 78°F | 29mm |
| Feb | 75°F | 126mm | 78°F | 28mm |
| Mar | 76°F | 124mm | 78°F | 29mm |
| Apr | 76°F | 232mm | 79°F | 40mm |
| May | 77°F | 262mm | 80°F | 82mm |
| Jun | 78°F | 335mm | 82°F | 54mm |
| Jul | 79°F | 323mm | 82°F | 93mm |
| Aug | 80°F | 308mm | 83°F | 121mm |
| Sep | 80°F | 261mm | 83°F | 126mm |
| Oct | 80°F | 166mm | 83°F | 122mm |
| Nov | 78°F | 120mm | 81°F | 120mm |
| Dec | 76°F | 144mm | 80°F | 47mm |
For the Big Island, aim for late spring and early summer (April-June) for pleasant weather and fewer crowds. For St. Thomas, the sweet spot is winter and early spring (December-May) for escape from colder climates and ideal beach conditions.
Browse Lonely Planet, Fodor's, Rick Steves, and more on Amazon — packed with maps, itineraries, and local tips.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
We'll send you the best destinations to visit each month — right timing, less crowds.