For dramatic natural wonders and a unique cultural experience, choose the Big Island. For classic Caribbean beach relaxation and vibrant snorkeling, St. Thomas is the superior choice.
This comparison is close. Check live prices for both destinations before you decide, flight pricing often makes the winner obvious.
Choosing between the majestic landscapes of Hawaii's Big Island and the sun-drenched shores of St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands, offers two distinct, yet equally enticing, tropical getaway experiences. The Big Island, the youngest of the Hawaiian Islands, is a testament to raw, natural power, boasting active volcanoes, diverse microclimates ranging from lush rainforests to arid lava fields, and a unique Polynesian culture deeply intertwined with its environment. In contrast, St. Thomas offers the quintessential Caribbean charm, characterized by turquoise waters, pristine beaches, vibrant coral reefs perfect for snorkeling, and a lively, yet relaxed, atmosphere infused with a rich colonial history.
Your decision hinges on the type of tropical adventure you seek. If your heart yearns for dramatic geological wonders, unparalleled stargazing, and a profound connection with nature's forces, the Big Island beckons. Conversely, if your ideal vacation involves sinking your toes into soft sand, exploring colorful underwater worlds, and immersing yourself in a lively Caribbean vibe with easy access to duty-free shopping, St. Thomas will undoubtedly capture your spirit.
| Month | Big Island, Hawaii High | Big Island, Hawaii Rain | St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands High | St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands Rain |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan | 81°F | 100mm | 84°F | 50mm |
| Feb | 81°F | 80mm | 84°F | 40mm |
| Mar | 81°F | 70mm | 86°F | 50mm |
| Apr | 82°F | 60mm | 86°F | 70mm |
| May | 82°F | 50mm | 88°F | 100mm |
| Jun | 84°F | 40mm | 88°F | 110mm |
| Jul | 84°F | 50mm | 88°F | 110mm |
| Aug | 86°F | 60mm | 88°F | 120mm |
| Sep | 84°F | 70mm | 88°F | 130mm |
| Oct | 84°F | 90mm | 86°F | 120mm |
| Nov | 82°F | 110mm | 86°F | 90mm |
| Dec | 81°F | 120mm | 84°F | 60mm |
The Big Island's dry season from April to October is ideal for exploring its volcanic landscapes, while the winter months offer whale watching and a unique festive spirit. St. Thomas shines between December and May for its consistently sunny days and gentle breezes, perfect for beach activities and enjoying the island's vibrant culture.
Browse Lonely Planet, Fodor's, Rick Steves, and more on Amazon — packed with maps, itineraries, and local tips.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Browse Lonely Planet, Fodor's, Rick Steves, and more on Amazon — packed with maps, itineraries, and local tips.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
We'll send you the best destinations to visit each month — right timing, less crowds.