Question 1

Is Big Island, Hawaii, Hawaii, USA or St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands cheaper?

Accepted Answer

Generally, St. Thomas can be more budget-friendly, especially for accommodations and dining, particularly during its shoulder seasons. While both can be expensive, the overall cost of a trip to St. Thomas might be slightly lower than to the Big Island, which often involves longer flight times and potentially higher resort prices.

Question 2

Which is better in summer?

Accepted Answer

For summer travel, the Big Island generally offers more favorable conditions. While both destinations are warm, St. Thomas experiences higher humidity and a greater chance of rainfall during the summer months. The Big Island, particularly on its western side, tends to have more consistent sunshine and less humidity during this period, making it a more comfortable choice for summer exploration.

Question 3

Big Island, Hawaii, Hawaii, USA or St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands for first-time visitors?

Accepted Answer

For a classic Caribbean beach vacation with easy accessibility and plenty of relaxation, St. Thomas is often a great choice for first-time visitors. However, if you're looking for a more adventurous and diverse experience that encompasses unique natural wonders and a different cultural landscape, the Big Island can also be an incredible introduction to Hawaii, though it requires a bit more planning due to its size and varied geography.

Question 4

How far apart are Big Island, Hawaii, Hawaii, USA and St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands?

Accepted Answer

These two destinations are located on opposite sides of the United States and are very far apart. They are separated by thousands of miles of ocean and require significant travel time, typically involving multiple flights. Direct flights between them are virtually non-existent, so you would likely need to fly back to the mainland U.S. and then connect to your next destination.

Question 5

Can you visit both Big Island, Hawaii, Hawaii, USA and St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands in one trip?

Accepted Answer

While technically possible, visiting both the Big Island and St. Thomas in a single trip is not practical or recommended for most travelers due to the immense distance and travel time involved. The transit alone would consume a substantial portion of your vacation, making it a rushed and expensive experience. It is best to choose one destination for a focused and enjoyable trip.

Month	Big Island, Hawaii High	Big Island, Hawaii Rain	St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands High	St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands Rain
Jan	81°F	60mm	84°F	60mm
Feb	81°F	50mm	84°F	50mm
Mar	82°F	50mm	86°F	50mm
Apr	82°F	40mm	86°F	70mm
May	84°F	30mm	88°F	100mm
Jun	84°F	20mm	88°F	110mm
Jul	86°F	30mm	88°F	120mm
Aug	86°F	40mm	88°F	130mm
Sep	86°F	40mm	88°F	140mm
Oct	84°F	60mm	86°F	130mm
Nov	82°F	70mm	86°F	110mm
Dec	81°F	70mm	84°F	70mm

Big Island, Hawaii vs St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands: Which Should You Visit in 2026?

Quick Verdict

Weather Comparison: Big Island, Hawaii vs St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands

When to Visit

Big Island, Hawaii vs St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands: Pros & Cons

Big Island, Hawaii

St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands

Frequently Asked Questions

Book Your Trip

Big Island, Hawaii

St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands

Explore Full Destination Guides