For travelers prioritizing diverse natural wonders and volcanic landscapes, the Big Island is the top choice. For those seeking classic Caribbean beach relaxation and vibrant underwater exploration, St. Thomas is the clear winner.
Big Island, Hawaii comes out ahead more often in this comparison. Check live prices before you book, especially if your dates are flexible.
Choosing between the Big Island of Hawaii and St. Thomas in the U.S. Virgin Islands offers two distinct yet equally captivating tropical island experiences. While both promise sun-drenched beaches and warm ocean breezes, their landscapes, activities, and overall vibes are remarkably different. The Big Island, the youngest and largest of the Hawaiian Islands, is a land of dramatic contrasts, from active volcanoes and lava fields to lush rainforests and snow-capped peaks. St. Thomas, on the other hand, is a quintessential Caribbean paradise, known for its crystalline turquoise waters, vibrant coral reefs, and charming colonial history.
If you're seeking raw, untamed natural beauty and a sense of adventure shaped by volcanic forces, the Big Island beckons. Conversely, if your dream vacation involves idyllic beaches, world-class snorkeling, and a more laid-back, Caribbean rhythm, St. Thomas might be your ideal escape. Consider what kind of memories you want to create: will it be the awe-inspiring power of Pele, the Hawaiian volcano goddess, or the serene beauty of a Caribbean sunset reflecting on calm waters?
| Month | Big Island, Hawaii High | Big Island, Hawaii Rain | St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands High | St. Thomas, US Virgin Islands Rain |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan | 81°F | 75mm | 84°F | 50mm |
| Feb | 81°F | 60mm | 84°F | 40mm |
| Mar | 81°F | 65mm | 86°F | 40mm |
| Apr | 82°F | 50mm | 86°F | 70mm |
| May | 82°F | 40mm | 88°F | 100mm |
| Jun | 84°F | 25mm | 88°F | 110mm |
| Jul | 84°F | 30mm | 88°F | 110mm |
| Aug | 84°F | 35mm | 88°F | 120mm |
| Sep | 84°F | 45mm | 88°F | 140mm |
| Oct | 82°F | 70mm | 86°F | 130mm |
| Nov | 82°F | 80mm | 86°F | 100mm |
| Dec | 81°F | 90mm | 84°F | 60mm |
The Big Island is most pleasant from April to June and September to October, offering good weather and fewer crowds. St. Thomas is best visited from December to May, avoiding the heavier rainfall and higher humidity of the summer and fall months, while enjoying a warm escape from colder climates.
Browse Lonely Planet, Fodor's, Rick Steves, and more on Amazon — packed with maps, itineraries, and local tips.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
We'll send you the best destinations to visit each month — right timing, less crowds.